Dangerous Mistakes Tripled in Maryland Hospitals

In the realm of healthcare, trust is the cornerstone upon which every successful patient-provider relationship is built. We rely on hospitals to be sanctuaries of healing, places where expertise and compassion converge. However, recent revelations about patient safety in Maryland have cast a sobering light on the state of affairs within its hospitals.

Between 2019 and 2022, incidents resulting in harm or injury to patients tripled, reaching an unprecedented peak. This surge, undoubtedly exacerbated by staffing shortages and the enduring weight of the pandemic, has highlighted systemic issues within Maryland’s Department of Health, including lax safety standards, insufficient reporting practices, and a critical need for enhanced oversight.

The alarming rise in patient safety incidents

Statistics reveal a stark escalation in patient safety incidents within Maryland’s hospitals over a three-year span, spiking from 2019 to 2022. The reported incidents of harm or injury to patients during this period totaled a staggering 769 cases. These numbers represent the highest level recorded since the state commenced comprehensive data collection on patient safety back in 2004. Many healthcare workers have indicated staffing shortages, as well as the relentless strain imposed by the pandemic on the healthcare system, as the primary cause of this influx.

Among the reported incidents, a few stand out as especially egregious. A premature baby was given four times the safe daily dose of a steroid, which continued over an extended 13-day period before the mistake was corrected. In a separate incident, a maintenance worker inadvertently shut off an unlabeled oxygen line, leading to the tragic deaths of three patients. Other cases describe surgeons operating on the wrong body parts, patients in crisis committing suicide after being left alone, and avoidable errors leading to amputations.

The fallout of a cybersecurity breach

While patient safety incidents surged, data surrounding these incidents was compromised. The December 2021 cybersecurity breach had profound implications on the accessibility of patient safety data, leaving the Maryland Department of Health unable to effectively track critical incidents within the state’s hospitals. The loss of access to vital information also hindered the department’s ability to address numerous patient safety concerns during a period of heightened strain on the healthcare system.

However, the cybersecurity breach was not made readily apparent to the general population. For months, the surge in patient safety incidents remained hidden from public view. The delayed disclosure of the breach significantly impacted public awareness, creating a sense of unease among Maryland citizens and eroding confidence in the transparency of the healthcare system.

Challenges in reporting and investigating adverse events

Maryland’s healthcare system, like many others, hinges on the voluntary reporting of adverse events by hospitals themselves. While this approach aims to foster a culture of accountability and transparency, it can also create a climate where incidents are omitted from official records. This is especially concerning in the context of a significant rise in incidents of patient harm, as observed in the years between 2019 and 2022. While plenty of alarming cases have come to light during this period, it is possible that hundreds more were never made public or even reported.

Moreover, certain laws and standards designed to protect both patients and healthcare workers can create unforeseen barriers to public awareness. To promote thorough data collection, individuals within the healthcare industry are encouraged to report patient safety incidents without fear of scrutiny or repercussions. Thus, the specific facility where an incident took place, the individuals involved, and other details are typically kept confidential.

The responsibilities of hospitals and the Department of Health

In the intricate web of healthcare regulation, both the Department of Health and individual hospitals shoulder significant legal responsibilities. These obligations are the bedrock upon which patient safety rests. The Department of Health, as the overseeing authority, is tasked with ensuring that hospitals within the state meet and maintain rigorous standards of care.

Individual hospitals, as integral components of the healthcare system, bear their own set of legal obligations. They are mandated to provide a standard of care that is commensurate with the prevailing medical standards and tailored to the unique needs of each patient. This duty extends to maintaining a safe environment, minimizing risks, and promptly addressing any incidents of harm or injury that may occur within their walls. Failure to meet these obligations can have far-reaching consequences, including potential legal liabilities.

Patient safety metrics

Currently, Maryland ranks 50th among the states for the longest emergency room wait times. In addition, Maryland is ranked 35th for patient safety by The Leapfrog Group, a private organization that assesses hospital safety metrics. This ranking is a composite of various factors, including hospital-acquired infection rates, surgical complications, and adherence to safety protocols. Out of 62 hospitals in the state, only nine received an A in safety.

While many medical professionals have highlighted pandemic strain and understaffing as the central source of the surge in negative incidents, it is clear that deeper systemic issues are also at play. These incidents, ranging from medication errors to critical missteps in surgical procedures, cannot always be explained away as the consequences of a workforce spread too thin. Rather, many of these issues seem to indicate underlying problems within the healthcare system itself.

Addressing systemic failures

The pandemic undoubtedly contributed to the heightened pressure on healthcare providers. However, attributing the surge in incidents solely to pandemic strain and staffing shortages oversimplifies the complex landscape of patient safety. Lax enforcement of safety standards significantly increases the likelihood of critical missteps. Furthermore, many of the incidents that have come to light suggest a need for enhanced training, particularly in high-risk domains like surgical procedures and medication administration.

In the pursuit of a safer and more resilient healthcare system, it is imperative that Maryland, as well as every other state, not only addresses immediate challenges but also commits to a sustained effort in upholding the highest standards of patient safety.

Please contact Paulson & Nace, PLLC through this contact form or by calling our office.